Is there a risk of institutional deadlock?
The resumption of the Territorial Council’s meeting on Saturday failed to break the deadlock. Following accusations of a “dictatorship” levelled the previous day against Louis Mussington, this time it was the president who denounced a “ farce ”. Two days of confrontations have revealed the extent of the political divide, with the threat now of a deadlock in the institutions.
More than an hour late, Louis Mussington resumed the meeting by offering his apologies, acknowledging a difficult situation from which only dialogue could provide a way out. He proposed the creation of a joint committee to examine the requests and their implications, pointing out that the renewal of the Executive Council did not constitute a change of term of office.
The debates resumed where they had left off the previous day, namely on the appointment of the newly elected members to head the subsidiary bodies and committees (in accordance with Article LO6321-25 of the General Code of Local Authorities) and, in particular, at the Tourist Office, due to its lack of transparency, and Semsamar, which is facing a significant budget deficit.
The Chairman maintained his refusal to proceed immediately with these appointments, on the grounds that they were not on the agenda.
“We do not negotiate the law; we simply apply it,” retorted the elected representatives of the diverse opposition, pointing out that they were not asking for a favour, but for the exercise of powers provided for by the organic law.
Dictatorship and farce
Louis Mussington denounced what he regarded as a ploy by the opposition, describing the previous day’s events as a ‘Trojan horse’ and a ‘farce’. Mélissa Nicolas-Rembotte contested this interpretation, explaining that the twelve elected representatives’ action stemmed from a desire for transparency, following several years of requests for documents that had gone unanswered. Philippe Philidor pointed out that the renewal of the executive had been made possible by the inclusion, on the President’s initiative, of a provision to replace one of its members. Following a further adjournment, requested by the opposition to consider how to proceed, Mélissa Rembotte announced that the elected representatives did not wish to continue the proceedings under these circumstances, denouncing what they regarded as an institutional deadlock attributable to the president. A further motion was tabled, calling for an urgent convening of the Territorial Council and the disclosure of all documents relating to the acquisition of the Beauperthuy plots. In the absence of a quorum, Louis Mussington was forced to adjourn the sitting and indicated that he would examine the motion tabled.
Is the Collectivité heading for paralysis?
In two days, the debates have not progressed beyond the first item on the agenda. The conflict now goes beyond the simple issue of appointments: it pits two interpretations of institutional prerogatives against one another, against a backdrop of control over satellite organisations and the Collectivité’s decisions.
This confrontation could soon have consequences for public policy. Tax reform, funding for the Concordia media library and the Grand Case Community Centre, the adoption of the flag… all these matters remain pending. If every sitting is hampered by the same disagreements, the very functioning of the institution could be jeopardised.
In a statement issued on Monday, the 12 elected representatives of the diverse opposition referred to a possible motion of no confidence, in accordance with Article LO 6322-4 of the General Code of Local Authorities. They insist this is not a course of action they are seeking, but one they might consider if the president persists in preventing the assembly, in their view, from exercising its responsibilities. The state authorities have been informed and say they remain open to a final attempt at dialogue. But how far could this confrontation go? With four months to go before the local elections, the president and the new majority will have to find a way to work together. In the absence of a compromise or legal arbitration, the risk is no longer merely that of a political crisis, but of the Collectivité becoming paralysed.