A particularly moving hearing
Cases of domestic violence are all too common, but last week the hearing took an unexpected turn.
A defendant appeared in court on charges of violence involving the use or threat of a weapon. The allegations against her were then set out in great detail: following an argument with her ex-partner, a woman attacked him so violently that the man called the police, who arrived at the scene to calm her down and asked her to return home. It was around 10.30 pm. Everything seemed to be returning to normal, but, unable to control her rage and having forgotten her mobile phone, she decided to go back, and there a veritable avalanche of violence and insults rained down on the man for much of the night.
She threatens to hit him with various objects and smashes much of the furniture in a fit of hysteria, forcing the man to call the police a second time; this time, they take the woman into custody to ensure she keeps quiet. It is 5.30 am; the episode comes to an end until the man goes to file a complaint regarding the events detailed by the judge and commented on by the public prosecutor in a tone that speaks volumes about the fact that she does not really approve of the defendant’s behaviour.
Love is a form of control
When given the floor, she acknowledges that her behaviour was excessive, but above all she reveals the true causes of her anger, admitting that the relationship she had been in with this man for several months had quickly become unbearable. Day after day, he made her life a living hell, keeping her under a stranglehold from which she could not escape. He toyed with her like a cat with a ball of wool, keeping her at his mercy without her being able to resist. At the time, she naively thought that things might change; indeed, this is what she told the prosecutor when asked why she had stayed – she did not reply ‘because I loved him’, but it was implied.
The defence lawyer, in his closing speech, rightly asserts that ‘love is a hold from which one cannot escape’. The woman does not deny the charges against her, admitting that she didn’t recognise herself that evening and that she’d lost her temper, but above all that no mention had been made of the fact that the man had also behaved very violently towards her, throwing her violently against the walls and even attempting to strangle her, using his strength and bulk to assault her without any restraint.
Deep emotion
During her statement, she stands upright and dignified at the witness box; she speaks in a clear voice but cannot hold back the sobs that speak volumes about her suffering, and as the proceedings progressed, a strange reversal of circumstances took place, shifting the defendant from the dock to the victims’ bench in a courtroom bathed in a heavy silence, such was the intensity of the emotion. However, a sense of bewilderment remains when the woman explains that she had to insist and involve her solicitor to file a complaint, but that it was dismissed (in other words, it’s first come, first served – Ed.).
In a case such as this, it is clear that the acts of domestic violence have been established and that, contrary to appearances, the victim is not necessarily the person initially identified as such.
The prosecutor was under no illusion, for in her closing speech she adopted a tone that practically argued in favour of the defendant, recommending a sentence far lighter than the one she had envisaged upon simply reading the case file (namely a few months’ suspended sentence). The woman left the courtroom, her face bearing the marks of this trial by truth, which had brought to light the unspeakable actions of a man unworthy of the name.